Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts

Monday, May 11, 2026

Audiobooks: A Return to Literature and its Innovation

 Introduction

            In the past several years, a new generation of readers have turned to the digital space for media consumption. Although one might assume that this draws readers away from literature, it has returned much of the pass-time’s popularity through the increasingly successful audiobook medium. Whether it is through purchase, pirating, libraries, iPhones or CDs, the accessibility of audiobooks allows many readers to indulge in all kinds of literature through an alternative medium. While audiobooks may have begun as a tool for those who have difficulty reading physical text, their popularity allowed creators to transform them into a modern art form. Their status as a form of book is debated amongst passionate page readers and advocated for by those who enjoy the accessibility and presence of the audio form. That public discourse of readers, writers, publishers, professors, and other literature lovers make up a community that controls the rhetoric of advances in the book industry. The recent increase in audiobook listeners and production quality has changed how the literary world understands modern reading and writing. To break down the audiobook industry’s effect on the future of the literary community one should focusing on the origin, intentions, and creation of the audiobook itself.

A Condensed History of Auditory Stories

The audiobook’s story began long before the technology for voice recording existed with the original form of storytelling: oral tradition. In prehistoric times many ancient people groups across the globe told stories of folktales, memories, or legends. The public act of recalling historical events, reciting musical ballads, and speaking poetry heavily impacted the creation of world cultures. Listeners recognize that the orators voice, experiences, and proximity will undoubtably have some effect on the story itself making the tradition a form of artistic expression. Academics in the world of oral tradition call these discrepancies “variations within limits” or “flexibility within the rules” (Garner, 2016). Interpretation is a part of any tradition, and the diversity in oral storytelling brings personality to the genre that makes stories unique to each storyteller. The slight variations in all storytelling are the root of “verbal art” which has impacted oral narratives throughout history (Garner, 2016). As more forms of writing were invented, performers began a new version of the oral tradition by reading texts aloud to eager audiences. At this time, verbal artistry transitioned to a matter of inflection and presentation rather than alterations to an author’s work.

The tradition continued to adapt with advances in technology, perhaps most importantly when Thomas Edison invented a little thing called the phonogram and recorded “Mary Had a Little Lamb,” thus creating the first ‘audiobook’ in 1877 (Thompson, 2021). Audiobooks are now a common mode of digital reading. In the U.S., the Library of Congress has worked with public libraries to make “talking books” readily accessible since the Pratt-Smoot Act passed in 1931 (Dali & Brochu, 2020). Congress originally funded the project for adult books and eventually expanded it to all books in 1952. By 1966, Public Law 89-522 mandated that all public libraries make talking books available to readers with print disabilities (Dali & Brochu, 2020). At the time of these projects, multiple public institutions, such as the Canadian National Institute for the Blind, intentionally set out to record many different books for library use. From cassettes to CDs and iPods to iPhones, audiobooks are available through the vast majority of public libraries, and, while they are specifically intended for those with visual or mobility impairment, many non-impaired library goers use them. The oral tradition continues to be a sough after medium even in the digital form—an artistic expression as old as language itself.

Defining Audiobooks as Books

As this research currently understands audiobooks, it refers to them as an audio medium that is any recorded and verbalized form of a published book, both AI and human. Additionally, the resources and data used to make the following analysis are based on audiobook’s presence in the United States.

Technological advances have made books more accessible throughout much of history. In the past, especially before the Gutenberg printing press, owning a book and being literate were qualities generally reserved for the very wealthy and powerful. After the printing press, reading allowed many people in the lower classes to educate themselves to advance their social standing and career possibilities. It was only fairly recently that the rise in entertainment technology stole our attention away from reading. In fact, research now shows that reading for personal interest declines about 3% every year in the U.S. since 2007 (Bone et al., 2025). The invention of audiobooks combines modern entertainment culture with literary consumption. Although this may be a good thing for the prosperity of literature in modern society, it puts a foul taste in the mouths of those who disagree with the equation of listening to reading.

Therefore, the necessary first step of analyzing the effects of the audiobook form is to address the rather heated debate within the literary community: are audiobooks books? The unspoken, and perhaps overemphasized, crux of this argument, is that part of the modern purpose of books is to distance oneself from technology given its numerous negative effects (ie: shorter attention spans, “brain rot,” doom scrolling, etc.). However, a reader may simply not adhere to this goal, and the argument is rendered null. While there may be merits to the argument that listening to an audiobook is not by definition reading, the debate is unimportant if the consumer’s only goal is to understand the story. Purchasing an audiobook provides royalties to the author and the purchaser still enjoys the words the author crafted whether they are looking at ink on a page or listening sound waves. There is also the belief that print and publication legitimizes a story because, especially in the Western world, that is how readers recognize quality and value; however, many classic authors, such as Homer, were originally oral storytellers. (Dali & Brochu, 2020). Those authors are certainly given respect in the literary community.

            Furthermore, listening to audiobooks is a matter of accessibility. The application of judgment on audiobook consumers often overlooks the tool’s necessity for some individuals. Overall, it is a conversation of checking privilege. Librarians Dali and Brochu (2020) raised this question in their research in support of libraries advocating for audiobook inclusivity. They prompt other librarians to consider body ability, lifestyle, Western culture, literacy, citizenship, and language as forms of privilege in the argument against audiobooks. Therefore, the large audience of audiobook lovers occupy a valid space within the literary community because they are still absorbing and engaging with literature. It is reasonable to define audiobooks as books and listening to them as parallel to reading.

The Increasing Popularity of Audiobooks

In all, audiobooks invite both previously proclaimed non-readers and adamant readers to consume more books quicker. According to the Audio Publishers Association (2025), audiobook sales revenue reached a record $2.22 billion in revenue in 2024 which was 13% higher than the previous year. In a 2025 Consumer Survey, the APA (2025) noted that 51% of 18 aged and older Americans have listened to an audiobook. The same survey found that General Fiction makes up the largest portion of audiobook revenue with Science Fiction, Fantasy, and Romance being the most popular sub-genres. Those statistics suggest that their may be a recent increase in leisure readers, at least in the audiobook world. These genre preferences also illustrate the current culture’s purpose for books: entertainment and distraction. Rather than reading for the primary purpose of education, enrichment is a passive consequence.

Of course, newer technologies, such as AI narration and YouTube make pirating audiobooks incredibly easy for readers that want to avoid any cost. Popular audiobook narrator Julia Whelan started her own company, Audiobrary, simply to supersede this issue by offering affordable rental audiobooks with a high quality that she believes AI can never meet (Peterson, 2026). Whelan’s philosophy revolves around using comparison as an argument. Audiobook narrators study the books they perform and bring the stories to life in the way a robots will never fully understand. Fully produced audiobooks can also implement multi person casts, music, and sound or voice effects to advance their quality against AI narrators. For readers that prefer audiobooks, the choice of where and how to acquire them primarily comes down to price and convenience. Oftentimes the quality is secondary. For example, Whelan, in a podcast interview with Anne Peterson (2026), mentioned her distaste for listening to audiobooks at faster speeds than their original recordings; however, she acknowledged that many neurodivergent people need to listen at the speed their brain processes information. In that case, the verbal art of audiobooks is displaced by the medium’s inclusivity and accessibility for readers that may struggle with reading quickly due to conditions such as Dyslexia or ADHD.

Changes for Authors

Although the vast majority of books are not written with the intention of an audio adaptation, the emerging patterns of genres and authors that prevail in audiobook sales is notable. As many contemporary authors write new books, knowing that many of their readers will be listening, is their writing affected by the possibility of audio adaptation? One author, Lucinda Berry (2025), has written two books with the full intention of them being audiobooks. She wrote these two projects in a script-form, similar to that of a radio drama, and her choices and writing style changed to fit the medium. For example, Berry considers audiobooks to have a certain confessional-like quality, so she structured her latest audiobook through therapy sessions.

Despite the lack of major contemporary authors speaking up about any effects the promise of adaptation has had on their writing, there are a litany of articles and blogs available online explaining how authors might alter their writing style to better suit the audiobook market. These recommendations include various ways to eliminate any misinterpretations in the narrator performance or reader listening through clear, simple sentences. Authors like Lucinda Berry testify that writing for audiobooks has improved their overall writing by making the text more focused and easier for listeners to multitask to. While this may be an improvement in the accessibility and ease of the medium, readers that choose to primarily listen may find that their stamina for more complex prose or analysis decreases as they continue to patron the audiobook industry.

Conclusion

The origins of all storytelling are auditory, but as technology has advanced, the literary community’s expectations for story and book quality have shifted to physical text. As audiobooks gain popularity and respect from many readers, the definition of “reading” has changed. It is no longer bound by the physical act of interpreting symbols into sounds and words. As an adjective, “reader” implies so much more than “one who reads books.” It describes a person that might engage with media platforms or fan bases or takes time to react to reviews of new publications. People that describe themselves as readers exist outside of printed pages on e-reader screens and absolutely in audiobooks. Although these books are perhaps less tangible and would shock the 15TH century monks that hand copied texts or the printers that composed one sheet at a time through movable block print, they are an adaptation of reading for the next generation. Just as each adaptation to book creation has compounded on its predecessor, audiobooks are a combination of contemporary print and the origins of storytelling. They meet the needs of current readers and allow them to engage with literature in a manner that suits 21ST century needs.

Despite debates on the merits of audiobooks, they have nevertheless changed the way many readers engage with stories by both providing more accessibility and presenting the possibility of simpler narratives exclusively in audio form. There is an interesting subcategory of reader that Don Katz, the CEO of Audible, calls a “media agnostic”—that is, those who do not recognize a difference between the visual text and auditory listening experience (Dali & Brochu, 2020). Although this is not every or even most readers, it presents a significant addition to the literary community. Going forward, research from the literary community needs to continue to explain the impacts, both benefits and possible detriments, of audiobooks. One aspect that particularly needs attention is the possibility that the promise of adaptation changes the way authors write stories. This applies to audiobooks but should be examined from the perspective of any audiovisual adaptation that an author knows will take place as they write their novel.         

Sources

Audio Publishers Association. (2025, June 2). The Audio Publishers Association Annual Survey Shows Audiobook Sales Grow to 2.22 Billion Dollars. https://www.audiopub.org/surveys

Berry, L. (2025, October 22). Audio Storytelling: How Writing Fuly-Produced Audiobooks Has Changed the Way I Write. Writer’s Digest. https://www.writersdigest.com/audio-storytelling-how-writing-fully-produced-audiobooks-has-changed-the-way-i-write

Bone, J.K, Bu, F., Sonke, J.K., Fancourt, D. (2025). The decline in reading for pleasure over 20 years of the American Time Use Survey. iScience, 28(9), 113288. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isci.2020.113288

Dali, K., Brochu, L. K. (2020, July). The Right to Listen: A Not So Simple Matter of Audiobooks. Public Knowledge Project, 64(3). https://doi.org/10.5860/lrts.64n3.106-119

Garner, L. A. (2016). Stories Which I Know to Be True: Oral Tradition, Oral History, and Voices from the Past. The Oral History Review, 43(2), 263–291. https://doi-org.libproxy.library.unt.edu/10.1093/ohr/ohw050

Kosch, L., Stocker, G., Ahrens-Schwab, A. & Boomgaarden, H. (2025, August). Media, modality, and motivation in literary-aesthetic experience: exploring auditory and visual reception of literature. Poetics, (3). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.poetic.2025.102021

Peterson, A.H. (Host). (2026, January 28). How an Audiobook Gets Made (with Julia Whelan!) [Audio podcast episode]. In Culture Study Podcast. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/culture-study-podcast/id1718662839?i=1000746994280

Thompson, J. B. (2021). The Remarkable Rise of the Audiobook. LOGOS: The Journal of the World Book Community, 32(2), 10–19. https://doi-org.libproxy.library.unt.edu/10.1163/18784712-03104013


Wednesday, February 12, 2025

Artificial Intelligence in the World of Publishing

 Introduction

In the past several years, generative artificial intelligence programs have made incredible breakthroughs in their usability, accuracy, and quality. As programs such as ChatGPT and Microsoft CoPilot become common use, many writers utilize AI in both creating and editing their product. As professionals in writing fields witness this progression, debate of quality control and confidential integrity has increased as publishers integrate AI into their policies and processes.

            Large language models (LLMs) are “deep learning models trained to understand and generate natural language” (Shen, et al.). Generative AI programs draw from LLMs, trained by public information, to answer user’s questions in simple chat form. The accessibility of this platform that arose in 2022 during ChatGPT’s premier was the ability to use 40 plus natural languages (English, Spanish, French, etc) instead of programming to communicate with AI. Now, writers and editors can use generative AI programs to create, edit, and analyze texts.

The recent developments in generative artificial intelligence programs impact the publishing industry through its implementation into writing, editing, and revising. This research examines how publishers, in both book and periodical and scientific and professional research, have integrated AI into their policies and the implications of those policies.

Literature Review

Generative artificial intelligence, being a relatively new and controversial topic, has acquired minimal research on industry specific use, including publishing. Valid analysis of AI’s interaction with humans is dated, because most modern content on the subject is generated by AI, not surprising given the subject matter. For example, the most recent app analysis of Wordcraft, an AI writing assistant program targeted at authors, was written entirely by Together AI. This research will dive more into the limitations and specifications publishers have placed on AI in their work based on existing policies and human perspective.

 In 2022, about a month before the premier of ChatGPT, Education and Information Technologies published “A Systematic Review of AI Technologies used for Story Writing,” in which they synthesized and analyzed existing story writing AI programs, and research on those programs, for their types, approaches, and roles (Fang et al). Primarily, existing research revolved around pedagogical uses for AI as it aids new writers with “various challenges when writing their digital stories,” such as creative strains, grammar questions, and technical challenges. The review also found that “AI played the role of story co-creator/ collaborator” when used by writers, similar to how career editors are traditionally utilized (Fang et al). Based on their research, authors of the review found two primary categories of use for AI in story writing: planning-based models and machine learning models. Writers can either use AI to outline their writing in an analogy structure with goal-directed approaches or use machine learning to complete or generate new content based on what is already written.

The Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) published a blog post with interviews from multiple editors on what the future of AI might mean for their industry specifically. Of the four editors interviewed, all agreed that they “don’t believe AI will ever replace human editors” (“What might the Future”). However, there is debate in the editing community over how influential implementing the programs will be on the industry. While some believe AI is too underdeveloped to ever aid the editing industry in any major capacity other than being a potential tool for “unconfident writers,” others are optimistic that it will speed up proofreading, copyediting, and copywriting processes (“What might the Future”). In editing, the 2022 review found that many story generators were “not error-less and may make grammatical mistakes and incoherent texts,” leaving a limitation that requires human oversight for generated works (Fang et al). In large part CIEP editors are not worried about AI replacing their positions meaning there is a general confidence in the publishing community that humans will always be at the center of good writing and editing despite AI improvements.

            A larger concern that this research will explore, is a movement for “better protections for authors,” so that their work cannot be “exploited in datasets to train,” LLMs or accessed before they’re published in a breach of confidentiality (“What might the Future”). ChatGPT is an especially popular and controversial AI system that trains its responses “on a diverse set of internet texts (approximately 570 GB), including books, articles, and websites,” in order to give a human-like range of responses in its chat structured feedback (Shen et al.). However, because ChatGPT uses such a wide range of sources, it can often provide incorrect or even incoherent information. This “hallucination effect is a common issue among many natural language processing models” (Shen et al.). Additionally, ChatGPT uses user data to train its LLM and give personalized feedback, meaning submitted information, like an unpublished manuscript, is archived and used in ChatGPT’s responses going forward.

            Furthermore, scientific researchers express a concern for ChatGPT’s “outright fabrication of scientific work” and citations causing AI-generated manuscripts to contain false facts (Shen et al.). Researchers warn editors and peer reviewers to “be aware that the submission of an entirely fabricated article, substantiated by synthetic data, images, and incorrect or misattributed citation, is inevitable” (Shen et al.). Publicists of non-fiction literature and research are aware that AI is not a reliable source for fact-checking information or providing reliable factual information and data.

A common alternative to ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot, is a program that protects users’ security and scrubs its training system of nefarious and misleading content (“Your Business Outcomes”). Copilot performs a similar function to ChatGPT but is more business oriented and therefore prioritizes responsible AI and produces sources linked to their responses. For the purposes of this researcher, Copilot is a program representative of developing technologies that addresses author privacy concerns and factual transparency.

Results and Analysis

The best way to analyze how publishers view and use AI is to examine the policies and statements that are currently accessible to the public. This information clarified the extent to which publishers have taken AI into account with their regards to their authors and editors. To obtain a broader view of current AI use in the publishing industry, I pulled editorial guidelines and statements on AI from 20 major publishing houses. This included both book and periodical publishers as well as scientific and professional research publishers.

Book and Periodical Publishers

The first table analyzes 10 book and periodical publishers. These distributors focus on longer form literary fiction and non-fiction on a regular schedule of production. Data from these publishers is implicit of more creative and long form writers.

Publisher

Where They’re Based

When the Policy was Produced

Policy

Allen and Unwin

Australia

NA/

No Statement

Chronicle Books

United States

NA/

No Statement

Grove Atlantic

United States

NA/

No Statement

Hachette Book Group

United Kingdom

April 2023

Open to “responsible experimentation” for operational uses, but relies on human creativity

HarperCollins

United States

November 2024

The first major publisher to strike a deal to sell authors books to an AI to train an LLM, possibly Microsoft

Pan Macmillan

United Kingdom

April 2023

Allows ethical use, but prioritizes creators and transparency

Explicitly protects writer’s data

Penguin-Random House

United Kingdom

August 2024

Uses AI, but relies on human creativity

Explicitly protects writer’s data

Scholastic

United States

NA/

No Statement

Simon & Schuster

United States

NA/

No Statement

Wiley

United States

September 2023

Requires human oversight of AI use and full transparency,

AI trade deal announced earlier this year


Of the 10 book and periodical publishers analyzed, 5 have yet to produce any public statement or policy change about their AI use as of November 2024. Four of the other publishers provided mild statements and policy additions that were minimal in their descriptions of its limitation, especially concerning editing. The descriptions of policies and beliefs were generally geared towards writers and underlined with fear of AI obtaining greater presence in the writing than the actual author. For example, Hachette states that they “encourage responsible experimentation with AI,” but also emphasizes that the book publishing “industry relies on the creative talent of humans” (“huk- Our Position on AI”). Additionally, publishers require full transparency that if the author should use AI in the writing, revision, and editing process they should disclose it to the publisher and readers.

 Penguin-Random House was the first publisher to add AI policies to their copyright protection statements on book prints in 2024. This protects writer’s material from data collection by generative AI systems, so that published works cannot be used to train LLMs. Editor’s main concern when using AI to assist in editing unpublished works is the potential of breaching an author’s confidentiality. For that reason, publishers do not allow editors to upload their client’s products into AI softwares. However, according to Michael Yukna, a Global Blackbelt in modern work at Microsoft who I interviewed, in systems like Copilot “confidentiality isn’t necessarily an issue. Copilot isn’t surfacing any data or information that a customer couldn’t have found themselves,” on the internet. Copilot doesn’t even use customer data and information to train its LLM. Training Copilot, according to Yukna, is on a personal basis within an individual chat to personalize feedback.

Conversely, HarperCollins and Wiley have both have formed quiet AI licensing deals in which they sell authorial content rights to train an LLMs. According to leaked information from the HarperCollins deal, the agreement was reached only after the unconfirmed company “agreed to several protective terms, including a commitment to limit verbatim reproduction and an agreement not to train on pirated content” (Albanese). This exemplifies Michael Yukna’s perspective when he said that at Microsoft, they “follow and adhere to very strict guidelines in terms of responsible AI,” (“Your Business Outcomes”). Those guidelines include fairness, reliability and safety, privacy and security, and inclusiveness. Potential partnerships to either use or sell content to AI companies must be filtered through these kinds of protective measures. AI engineers like Yukna are optimistic that AI is a safe tool for editors so long as they are maintained responsibly.

Although several of the analyzed publishers have not made any statements or policy changes regarding AI, that does not mean they’re not already using it. Sara Kocek, founder and editor at YellowBird Editors, and published author conveyed to me in an interview that, while YellowBird is currently crafting their AI policies, she already uses the technology in her personal writing. Kocek explained that “a lot of editors in [her] network” fear “that the work [they] put into AI will somehow be used to train other AIs, and that would be a breach of privacy.” This is a valid concern especially when the most common AI, ChatGPT has no protective qualities for submitted content. Using unspecified AI, even for copy editing and copy writing and even for actions such as drafting emails or creating summaries, is dangerous to perform without strict guidelines. Kocek agreed that “the question of whether it’s ok to [use AI on authorial clientele’s work] has not at large been answered in our industry yet, and until there’s a standard set about that” Kocek and others in the publishing industry do not and should not feel comfortable operating with AI.

As the largest publishers continue to produce new policies and licensing agreements with AI, they set a precedent for how this new technology will be implemented into the industry. With book and periodical publishing, it is critical that boundaries are set in both function and what program is used to prevent disruption of the system. Unregulated, AI in book and periodical publishing could quickly become a substitute for good authorship and detailed editors instead of a tool to improve writing. While deals such as those that HarperCollins and Wiley made are potentially dangerous for the integrity of author protection, they open up the potential for a clear relationship with AI.

Scientific and Professional Research Publishing

This table examines 10 major scientific and professional research publishers. These are quite different from the book and periodical publisher as they produce researched, factual data to advance professional fields of study. They focus more on proof reading and fact checking, often considered very objective elements of writing.

Publisher

Where They’re Based

When the Policy was Produced

Policy




Cambridge University Press

United Kingdom

2023

Use AI, but be transparent and do not violate plagiarism policies

Clarivate

United Kingdom

April 2023

Use with accountability and transparency

Using data to train AI requires requested license

Elsevier

The Netherlands

2023

Use with disclosure during the writing process, no co-authorship

Editors may not use to protect confidentiality and data

Frontiers

Switzerland

2023

Author accountability and transparency when using AI, no co-authorship

ORO Editions

United States

NA/

No Statement

Public Library of Sciences

United States

2023

Author accountability and transparency

RELX Group

United Kingdom

August 2024

Human oversight and accountability, strong data governance

Sage Publications

United States

2023

Welcomes AI use with full disclosure,

Editors present copyright issues

Springer Nature

United States

2023

Human accountability for generative work,

Explicitly protects data through peer reviewer’s AI use

Taylor and Francis Group

United Kingdom

March 2023

Welcomes AI use, author accountability and full disclosure,

Editor’s use of AI is a confidentiality infringement,

AI trade deal announced earlier this year

World Scientific Publishing

Singapore

2023

Author accountability and transparency,

Editors decide if AI is permissible

Of the 10 book and periodical publishers analyzed, 5 have yet to produce any public statement or policy change about their AI use as of November 2024. Four of the other publishers provided mild statements and policy additions that were minimal in their descriptions of its limitation, especially concerning editing. The descriptions of policies and beliefs were generally geared towards writers and underlined with fear of AI obtaining greater presence in the writing than the actual author. For example, Hachette states that they “encourage responsible experimentation with AI,” but also emphasizes that the book publishing “industry relies on the creative talent of humans” (“huk- Our Position on AI”). Additionally, publishers require full transparency that if the author should use AI in the writing, revision, and editing process they should disclose it to the publisher and readers.

 Penguin-Random House was the first publisher to add AI policies to their copyright protection statements on book prints in 2024. This protects writer’s material from data collection by generative AI systems, so that published works cannot be used to train LLMs. Editor’s main concern when using AI to assist in editing unpublished works is the potential of breaching an author’s confidentiality. For that reason, publishers do not allow editors to upload their client’s products into AI softwares. However, according to Michael Yukna, a Global Blackbelt in modern work at Microsoft who I interviewed, in systems like Copilot “confidentiality isn’t necessarily an issue. Copilot isn’t surfacing any data or information that a customer couldn’t have found themselves,” on the internet. Copilot doesn’t even use customer data and information to train its LLM. Training Copilot, according to Yukna, is on a personal basis within an individual chat to personalize feedback.

Conversely, HarperCollins and Wiley have both have formed quiet AI licensing deals in which they sell authorial content rights to train an LLMs. According to leaked information from the HarperCollins deal, the agreement was reached only after the unconfirmed company “agreed to several protective terms, including a commitment to limit verbatim reproduction and an agreement not to train on pirated content” (Albanese). This exemplifies Michael Yukna’s perspective when he said that at Microsoft, they “follow and adhere to very strict guidelines in terms of responsible AI,” (“Your Business Outcomes”). Those guidelines include fairness, reliability and safety, privacy and security, and inclusiveness. Potential partnerships to either use or sell content to AI companies must be filtered through these kinds of protective measures. AI engineers like Yukna are optimistic that AI is a safe tool for editors so long as they are maintained responsibly.

Although several of the analyzed publishers have not made any statements or policy changes regarding AI, that does not mean they’re not already using it. Sara Kocek, founder and editor at YellowBird Editors, and published author conveyed to me in an interview that, while YellowBird is currently crafting their AI policies, she already uses the technology in her personal writing. Kocek explained that “a lot of editors in [her] network” fear “that the work [they] put into AI will somehow be used to train other AIs, and that would be a breach of privacy.” This is a valid concern especially when the most common AI, ChatGPT has no protective qualities for submitted content. Using unspecified AI, even for copy editing and copy writing and even for actions such as drafting emails or creating summaries, is dangerous to perform without strict guidelines. Kocek agreed that “the question of whether it’s ok to [use AI on authorial clientele’s work] has not at large been answered in our industry yet, and until there’s a standard set about that” Kocek and others in the publishing industry do not and should not feel comfortable operating with AI.

As the largest publishers continue to produce new policies and licensing agreements with AI, they set a precedent for how this new technology will be implemented into the industry. With book and periodical publishing, it is critical that boundaries are set in both function and what program is used to prevent disruption of the system. Unregulated, AI in book and periodical publishing could quickly become a substitute for good authorship and detailed editors instead of a tool to improve writing. While deals such as those that HarperCollins and Wiley made are potentially dangerous for the integrity of author protection, they open up the potential for a clear relationship with AI.

Conclusion

            Based on my findings from analyzing publishers’ policies, Microsoft’s precedents, and specific editor’s habits, I can conclude that publishers view AI as a tool best used to assist inexperienced and short form writers in the publishing industry. Inexperienced writers, such as researchers with expertise in their field but little writing experience, can use generative AI the most as a tool to improve the quality of their writing and to communicate their findings more effectively. Additionally, other publishing jobs that are associated with short form writing, copywriting and copyediting, are at a higher risk of being replaced by generative AI because editors can use AI to complete those jobs for efficiently.

Book and periodical publishers lack specificity in their AI policy. Several have simply stated their opinions or stances on AI in their production but have not set out detailed criteria for what writers and editors can and cannot do. Any industry open to implementing AI should be clear on the limitations of its use to prevent leaking data or compromising writer integrity. This should include which AI programs to use as well as how and when to use them. Across the field, professionals in the publishing industry are optimistic about implementing AI into their work, but they are concerned about confidentiality, copy right, and human accountability. Programs, like Copilot, that prioritize responsible AI can address these concerns. Editors, as assistants to writers are not in danger of their jobs becoming obsolete because publishing experts continue to believe that “ultimately humans will always prefer to work with other humans,” over AI systems (“How might the Future”).

            Policies that do not specify the qualities of approved AI use and simply recommend some level of experimentation do not take into account the ease of falling into an abuse of AI where authors are no longer taking bulk responsibility for their work. The line between using AI as a tool for writing and using it a substitute to perform undesirable tasks is blurry and the best way to clarify that boundary is with precise guidelines. As technology advances and becomes more essential, boundaries are a necessity to protect the integrity of the publishing world. These boundaries should include both what AI programs to use and what instances writers and editors should use AI.

As Kocek explained, “What makes writing good is that it reminds us what it is to be human, and right now, AI can’t do that.” However, it would be a mistake to disregard such valuable technology out of fear of its complex nature. There is a path to managing that fear the same way writers moved from typewriters to computers. The specific qualifications of that path are yet to be established and the effects of these major changes on the industry will likely not be visible for the coming years. Both of these qualities, specification of policies and changes in written products, should be monitored and studied by professionals in the industry, and based on the variations within this research, the publishing field would benefit from coming together to standardize their AI policies.

Work Cited

“Ai Policy.” Taylor & Francis, 20 Aug. 2024, taylorandfrancis.com/our-policies/ai-policy/#:~:text=Taylor%20%26%20Francis%20strives%20for%20the,data%2C%20including%20personally%20identifiable%20information. 

Albanese, Andrew, et al. “Agents, Authors Question HarperCollins Ai Deal.” PublishersWeekly.Com, PWxyz LLC, 19 Nov. 2024, www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/publisher-news/article/96533-agents-authors-question-harpercollins-ai-deal.html. 

“Artificial Intelligence.” Clarivate, 1 Nov. 2024, clarivate.com/ai/. 

“Artificial Intelligence (AI).” Nature News, Nature Publishing Group, www.nature.com/nature-portfolio/editorial-policies/ai#ai-use-by-peer-reviewers. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024. 

Fang, Xiaoxuan, et al. “A Systematic Review of Artificial Intelligence Technologies Used for Story Writing - Education and Information Technologies.” SpringerLink, Springer US, 5 Apr. 2023, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10639-023-11741-5.

“Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence: About.” Frontiers, www.frontiersin.org/journals/artificial-intelligence/for-authors/author-guidelines. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024. 

“Generative Artificial Intelligence: A Balancing Act for Publishers.” Wiley Online Library, www.wiley.com/en-us/network/trending-stories/generative-artificial-intelligence-a-balancing-act-for-publishers. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024. 

“How We Are Thinking about AI at Pan Macmillan.” Pan Macmillan, Apr. 2024, www.panmacmillan.com/ai-at-pan-macmillan#:~:text=At%20Pan%20Macmillan%2C%20we%20have,reach%20more%20readers%20and%20listeners. 

“Huk – Our Position on Ai.” Hachette UK, 7 Mar. 2024, www.hachette.co.uk/landing-page/huk-our-position-on-ai/. 

“International Journal on Artificial Intelligence Tools.” World Scientific, www.worldscientific.com/worldscinet/ijait. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024. 

“Penguin’s Approach to Generative Artificial Intelligence.” Penguin Books UK, 8 Aug. 2024, www.penguin.co.uk/articles/2024/08/penguins-approach-to-generative-artificial-intelligence. 

“Publishing Ethics Authorship and Contributorship Journals.” Cambridge Core, www.cambridge.org/core/services/publishing-ethics/authorship-and-contributorship-journals. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024. 

“Research Integrity and Publication Ethics.” PLOS, 2 Apr. 2024, plos.org/research-integrity-and-ethics/#:~:text=What%20we’re%20doing%3A%20In,raised%20about%20AI%20tool%20usage. 

“Responsible Artificial Intelligence Principles at RELX.” RELX, www.relx.com/~/media/Files/R/RELX-Group/documents/responsibility/download-center/relx-responsible-ai-principles.pdf. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024. 

Shen, Yiqiu, et al. “CHATGPT and Other Large Language Models Are Double-Edged Swords” Radiology Society of North America, 26 Jan. 2023, pubs.rsna.org/doi/full/10.1148/radiol.230163. 

“The Use of Generative AI and Ai-Assisted Technologies in the Editing Process for Elsevier: Elsevier.” Www.Elsevier.Com, www.elsevier.com/about/policies-and-standards/publishing-ethics-books/the-use-of-generative-ai-and-ai-assisted-technologies-in-the-editing-process. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024. 

Together AI. “Word Craft.” Lab Lab AI, Wordcraft, 20 Oct. 2024, lablab.ai/event/edge-runners-3-point-2/wordcraft/word-craft. 

“Using AI in Peer Review and Publishing.” SAGE Publications Inc, 2 Aug. 2023, us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/using-ai-in-peer-review-and-publishing#pt3. 

“What Might the Future of AI Mean for Editors and Proofreaders?” CIEP Blog, 20 Oct. 2023, blog.ciep.uk/future-of-ai-for-editors/. 

“Your Business Outcomes. Our Services. #bettertogether.” Microsoft Adoption, 3 Nov. 2024, adoption.microsoft.com/. 



One Summer, Twenty Articles

 I opened my email in a fit of chasing dopamine, expecting to find another empty inbox. Instead,  a message Zach Yeager popped up, with a pr...